Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Notes on Social Capital Views

In Social Capital, by Nan Lin, presents some differing perspectives on social capital. I have made some notes of his assessment below, and have added some additional comments.

Bordieu - Social capital consists of social obligations or connections. It can be reduced to economic capital as it is viewed as collective asset that endows members with credits. The collective asset can be obtained through group membership.
Burt - Social capital is based on the number of people that an individual is connected to, the strength of these relationships, and the location the individual reside within this structure (see Flap's perspective). Individuals that bridge non-redundant groups of people have more social capital. Social capital accrues through bridging structural holes.
Coleman - Social capital is an aspect of social structure, and it facilitates certain actions of individuals within the structure. Social capital accrues through bonding.
Flap - Social capital consists of (1) the number of persons within one's social network who "are prepared or obliged to help you when called upon to do so," (2) the strength of the relationship indicating readiness to help, and (3) the resources of these persons.
Lin - Resources are divided into two types: personal and social. Personal resources include material objects (e.g, an airplane) and symbolic objects (e.g., a diplomas and degrees). Social resources, on the other hand, are resources accessed through an individual's social connections. Social resources, in both quantity and quality, far outweigh personal resources.
Putnam - Group level theory which tends to measure social capital collectively.

These notes are in no way conclusive or complete. However, they serve as a quick reminder to the various views.

Social Capital Explanations

In Nan Lin's book, Social Capital, he provides the following explanations as to why social capital works, or more clearly, why embedded resources in social networks enhance the outcomes of actions. They are as follows with an example of each (see pages 19-20):
  1. information flow is facilitated - word of mouth effect (e.g., being connected to people with useful information is a benefit)
  2. social ties may exert influence - some ties carry more weight (e.g., son of the President)
  3. social credentials - resources beyond an a single individuals' are available if necessary (e.g., politician endorsement)
  4. reinforcement identity and recognition - can provide support and public acknowledgment of one's claim of resources (e.g., maintenance of mental health and entitlement of resources)
Lin suggests that these four elements "may explain why social capital works in instrumental and expressive actions not accounted for by forms of personal capital such as economic or human capital."

I would agree and add that relationships among people add an additional layer of complexity that cannot be accounted using only individual centered metrics.

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Social Capital Simulation Updated


The social capital simulation has been improved! The usability has been improved, preset examples have been added, and additional information in now reported.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Social Connections in Decline

Robert Putnam, an influential social capital researcher, visited BYU nearly two years ago to discuss how social connections are on the decline. Here is good summary of Putnam's talk on BYU NewsNet. His research during the past decade has shown a negative trend in that people are socially connecting less these days. The speech gave fuel to the research on social networks that I had been involved in and has been a strong motivation to our current work on social capital.

Figure 1. "The TV Connection" shows that group membership tends to decline as television viewing increases among those having twelve or more years of education. (see The Strange Disappearance of Civic America)

Empirical studies on group membership, like the study shown in the plot above contribute to the evidence which Putnam uses to support this claim.

Social Capital Simulation (Online)

The past couple days I have been working on an online social capital simulation that was created primarily with Javascript. Currently, it calculates social capital in the same manner as the excel version, however, it is more powerful as it allows you to set how many nodes you would like in the network, it dynamically creates a visual graph of the network, and it is accessible online.
I used Walter Zorn's High Performance JavaScript Vector Graphics Library to draw the network (i.e., nodes, lines, and text). This is an impressive library, which makes drawing with Javascript more pleasant than I originally expected. Also, to facilitate this project, I extended Zorn's library by adding getColor, getOpacity, and setOpacity methods. Furthermore, Michael Deardeuff and other Data Mining Lab members used their keen pattern finding skills to develop the mathematical equation for node placement in the graph.

Let me know how it works for you. I want to make this available so that it is easy to for people to get a feel for how we calculate social capital, which will allow us to refine our method.

Friday, February 08, 2008

Burt's Views

I have been reading Ronald Burt's book called "Brokerage and Closure" to gain a better understanding of his view of social capital. Here are a few points that I have found interesting as I have read:

The value of a relationship is not defined inside the relationship; it is defined by the social context around the relationship" (Brokerage and Closure, pg. 11).

The "working definition" of a structural hole is the relationship between two people is a hole-spanning bridge when there is no effective indirect connection between the people. However, Burt does not wish to imply that the concept of a structural hole has an absolute meaning. He explains that structural holes could come and go by simply changing the population size of the network being analyzed. He argues that the same definitional issue exists for the absolute meaning of a relationship, a fundamental element of network theory (Brokerage and Closure, pg. 24).So, as an example, the structural hole in the network above is the relationship marked blue, while the value of that relationship is defined by the social context, or the other nodes in the network (i.e., A, B, G, E, F, H, and I).

Thursday, February 07, 2008

Gmail Temporarily Down

Dependence on Google is not always good. Here is the error message:


Update: Gmail is back up! The duration of the "Temporary Error" lasted about half an hour.

Tuesday, February 05, 2008

Book List: Social Capital

In my quest to better understand how sociologists view social capital, I visited the library and checked out the following books:
  • Structural holes : the social structure of competition Burt, Ronald S.
  • Brokerage and closure : an introduction to social capital Burt, Ronald S.
  • Applied network analysis : a methodological introduction Burt, Ronald S.
  • Social capital : theory and research Lin, Nan
  • New social ties : contemporary connections in a fragmented society Chambers, Deborah.
  • Complex social networks Vega-Redondo, Fernando.
  • Effective small group and team communication Hoover, Judith D. (Judith Davis)
  • The role of social capital in development : an empirical assessment Grootaert, Christiaan
  • Social capital : a theory of social structure and action Lin, Nan
  • The well-connected community : a networking approach to community development Gilchrist, Alison.
  • The Analysis of social interactions : methods, issues, and illustrations Cairns, Robert B.
Of course, I won't have time to read all of these books from cover to cover. However, I do plan on reading enough to understand how they define, calculate, and show the presence of social capital.

Monday, February 04, 2008

Social Capital Simulation

Our recent work has explored the concept of social capital, which I have discussed previously. Our social capital metrics, namely bonding and bridging (popularized by Robert Putnam), utilize the hybrid network methodology that we have developed for online communities.

To understand our metrics, I have created a basic social capital simulation (an excel spreadsheet) having five nodes. The simulation allows for you to change the connection strengths in both the implicit affinity network (IAN) and the explicit social network (ESN). Changing these values will give you an idea of how social capital fluctuates as the social network changes.

The figure above shows the initial configuration of the simulation. The dashed blue lines represent the IAN and the solid pink lines represent the ESN. The thicker the lines the stronger the connection. The weights for the IAN were randomly assigned, while the ESN weights were all set to one, thus creating a clique.

Initially, the bonding and bridging social capital are both 1, since everyone in the network is connected. To see how the social capital fluctuates, change the blue and/or pink values, again representing the IAN and the ESN weights respectively, in the spreadsheet.

Social Graph API by Google

Google's Social Graph API allows developers to utilize the public connections among people on the web. The idea is simple, yet it could make it easier for people to connect across sites. Of course, the data all comes through Google, which yet increases our dependence on them. No doubt, other search engines could easily create the same API.

Since Google already saves a copy of all of the web pages that it spiders for search, the task of extracting the annotated links is somewhat trivial. Currently, this will only work as web developers annotate user links with XHTML Friends Network (XFN) and Friend of a Friend (FOAF). It is a great idea, but may take some time before web developers start annotating.
Furthermore, the easy access to people's connections is a nice data source for some new applications and experiments.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Measuring Social Capital (Weekly Update)

During this week, I have been reading and thinking more about how to measure social capital. In the literature, there is no agreed upon definition of social capital nor is there any agreed upon method for measuring it. Therefore, proximal indicators are used to measure some believably related contributor to social capital.

For instance, Putnam has used the density of voluntary organizations (VOs) in a community to measure social capital. So, in this case, the density of VOs is a proximal indicator for social capital.

Nan Lin uses the number of connections an individual has weighted by the importance of the person.

Social Capital Survey Reading:
Social Capital: One or Many? by Martin Paldam (Economist)
Social Capital Survey by Tristan Claridge (in particular, see measurement)

Topic Tool

Today, I put together a web page topic tool by using the web service that Nathan Davis made available. The tool takes in one or more web pages (i.e., a list of URLs) and then extracts the topics given the text on the web pages. The topics, or more accurately, the most likely topic components are extracted using an algorithm called Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA).

One potential use is for quickly generating blogger profiles to be used for implicit affinity networks. You can try it out at:

http://dml.cs.byu.edu/matthewsmith/tools/topictool/

Nathan uses his web service to make the query expansion service for Google searches called GooEgg.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Social Capital Measurement

There are countless methods for measuring social capital. Below is a list of papers, studies, and resources that discuss some of these techniques:
More
It is clear that there are many ways to measure social capital. The techniques vary from discipline to discipline and researcher to researcher, whether it be Putnam or Burt, sociology or political science, the approaches tend to be different. Is there a chance for standardizing the definition? (Update: see more recent post for more on this)

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

DML Research Collaboration

In effort to collaborate and refine our research at a faster pace, it might be fun to (1) blog about our research ideas each week and then (2) visit each lab member's blog to comment on what they have written to encourage good ideas and weed out the bad.

What do you think?

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Weekly Update

The tasks that I was involved (and some thoughts) during this week include the following:

Outlined a preliminary schedule and brainstormed for the "Making a Blog Big" project with Nathan Purser

Read more about Structural Holes and Network Closure, including:
  • Ronald Burt's Structural Holes versus Network Closure (PDF). Notes:
    • Some more quickly become prominent; some enjoy higher incomes; some lead more important projects; the interests of some are better served than interests of others. Better connected people enjoy higher returns. (These are some things that we could use to validate our social capital metrics.)
    • The Social Capital Metaphor is "people that are better connected do better", whereas the Human Capital Metaphor is "people who do better are more able individuals; they are more intelligent; more attractive; more articulate; more skilled."
    • A generic research finding in sociology and social psychology is that information circulates more within than between groups
    • Social capital can be argued to exist in structural holes (bridging) and network closures (bonding). However, the studies he performs and shows indicate that structural holes are the source of social capital.
    • Networks of densely interconnected contacts are systematically associated with substandard performance (bonding); networks that span structural holes are associated with creativity and innovation, positive evaluations, early promotions, high compensation and profits (bridging).
    • There remains an important role for closure. It can be critical to realizing the value buried in structural holes.
    • The mechanisms remain distinct. Closure describes how dense or hierarchical networks lower the risk associated with transaction and trust, which can be associated with performance. The hole argument describes how structural holes are opportunities to add value with brokerage across the holes, which is associated with performance.
  • Bruce Hoppe's blog post, Reputation and Trust (aka "Network Closure")
    • Uses a good personal example of Network Closure
    • I commented, "Virtual communities, no doubt, have an impact on real communities. However, I would argue that Putnam's work stands as does Burt's. The main issue seems to be that social capital is challenging to define precisely. Are there any agreed upon mathematical definitions of social capital? (It seems that there is still too much ambiguity.)"
Reading that I like to get to:
Found some other interesting resources, along the way: